The Devialet D-Premier integrated amp/DAC (HiFi+ 75)

 

The first person I met who had heard about the Devialet D-Premier was French. He spoke animatedly of the category-busting Class ADH integrated amplifier/DAC, his speech full of superlatives, his hands bursting with extravagant gestures and his eyes wild with passion and drama. I put it down to a Frenchman being French about something French.

Then I started seeing the same symptoms from others who had experienced the D-Premier. Not just French people; people of all nationalities and fans of all musical genre, died in the wool measurement-led types or fairy-foo folk who believe electricity is made in the caves of the Dwarf-Lords of Moria. They all started discussing the product with a high degree of animation. Even the normally down-to-earth Paul Miller, editor of rival UK audio magazine Hi-Fi News & Record Review, was seen to be shouting about just how important this product really is.

So, either the Devialet D-Premier is something really special, or it’s the audio equivalent of those man-sized seed-pods in The Invasion of the Body Snatchers; people walk into a room with the D-Premier, and come out a few minutes later… changed. I decided to investigate.

A part of the reason why the measurement types are so excited about the Devialet D-Premier is it’s something genuinely new and original. While each new product has legitimate reasons to highlight its novel aspects of design and implementation, deep down the changes are variations on one of several themes, no matter how good those themes, how innovative those variations or how remarkable the final result. A Class AB amplifier may differ in many ways from another Class AB amplifier, but the basic design of the amplifier circuit remains fundamentally the same.

The Devialet designers didn’t approach the concept in the same way. They looked at what an amplifier has to do for a living in the first decade of the 21st Century and designed a product tabula rasa (blank slate) to accommodate those demands. People today, it seems, don’t want a plethora of large, hot-running boxes that take a month before they sound good. They will increasingly rely on digital-only systems, despite recent improvements in the fortune of vinyl replay. They need enough power to drive today’s more punishing loudspeaker loads, but enough finesse to make that process sound good regardless. Last, but not least, it needs to be easy to use and look very cool.

The designers – Pierre-Emannuel Calmel and Matthias Moronvalle, both from the R&D department from telecoms giant Nortel – set about designing an amplifier circuit that is both incredibly linear and highly efficient, utilising the advantages of both Class A and Class D amplifier designs. What they came up with was ‘Class ADH’ – a hybrid of analogue Class A amplifiers and a digital Class D design.

How this works is to have a small Class A amplifier directly coupled to the loudspeaker, to provide the voltage, while the Class D amplifier provides almost all the current needed to drive the loudspeaker. If you disabled the Class D circuit, you’d have something that would be capable of driving horn loudspeakers and headphones in its own right, but the hired muscle of the Class D amp bestows the same linearity to more demanding loudspeaker loads. Eagle-eyed readers with long memories might note that this concept is not far removed from the Quad ‘current dumping’ 405 amplifier of the 1970s. It’s brought bang up to date, but the concept is similar.

It’s important to stress that the ‘D’ in Class D does not stand for ‘digital’. In fact, Class D is a highly efficient high-frequency switching amplifier. However, in the case of the Devialet, the Class D stage is fed by digital processors, so that it receives a digital 300kHz PWM (pulse width modulation) signal. So, it really is a Digital Class D design.

That in and of itself would be enough to impress people, but the rest of the story is just as impressive. The power output (nominally 165W per channel into eight ohms) can be remapped (akin to ‘chipping’ a sports car’s engine management system) to deliver anything from 160-240W, special loads on the phono input and more will be addressable though downloading onto an SD card (supplied). The amplifier treats all sources identically, immediately digitising analogue sources through a high-quality 48kHz ADC, with the Class D amp remaining in PWM mode up to the output devices and the Class A stage only receiving the output of two Burr Brown chips at the last possible moment. Yet again, this isn’t handled in the normal manner, Devialet using what is called a ‘current reflector’ layout.

Those who read digital circuits in the way most of us wish we could read cooking instructions seem to make this low ‘wwwwwwwwwwwwwowww’ noise. Digital engineers patently behave in a very 19th Century manner – since I received the D-Premier, I have had emails from engineers wishing me to pass on their respect and admiration.

Comments

SlickenSmooth -- Tue, 11/09/2010 - 21:13

Would you say that this will fare in the same water as the Soulution pre and stereo poweramp? Or doesn't it compete with the top amps like Spectral, Balabo, Tenchical Brain, Soulution, ARC?

Silence is Music

Mr Plus -- Thu, 11/18/2010 - 04:38

Put simply, yes. I don't have much experience with BaLabo or Technical Brain (neither product being currently sold in the UK). However, the Devialet is in exactly the same league as the top amps. Which is what makes it so exciting, IMO.

Alan Sircom
Editor, Hi-Fi Plus Magazine
London, England
editor [at] hifiplus [dot] com

SlickenSmooth -- Thu, 11/18/2010 - 06:42

I have already ordered mine! Thanks for your reply. Right now I'm thinking wether I should go for the Macbook pro/ Weiss INT202/ Ipad remote route or import the audiophile computer from bluesmokesystems as it's not being sold here in Europe. Have you listened to this computer by any chance?

Silence is Music

Mr Plus -- Thu, 11/18/2010 - 08:01

The Bluesmoke is yet another product that doesn't figure in the UK, I'm afraid. However, I've used the Devialet with a number of analogue and digital sources. The MBP/Weiss/iPad option is an exceptionally good one, especially as you can use AES/EBU. This is Devialet's preferred choice of digital ingress.

I'm also having something of an about face with the analog inputs. They are a lot more than just legacy.

I'd say I hope you enjoy the D-Premier, but I don't think there's much need for 'hope'. Good choice!

Alan Sircom
Editor, Hi-Fi Plus Magazine
London, England
editor [at] hifiplus [dot] com

curbfeeler -- Tue, 11/23/2010 - 15:22

There appears to be a factual error in Alan’s reporting. Rather than 48 kHz, the conversion resolution at the analog inputs is greater. From the FAQ at Devialet - Analog inputs: We have decided to convert them using high resolution sample rates (96 or 192kHz - 24 bit), so all signals follow the same path, and go through the internal DAC of the D-Premier. This architecture is the result of extensive studies to achieve optimal volume control linearity and highly contributes to its unique performances and great versatility. Therefore we guarantee the quality of the audio result.
I read through the HiFi+ article and the specifications at the website without learning how capable the digital inputs are. Found it in the FAQ. Digital Input Resolution: All digital inputs of the D-Premier admit high resolution PCM signals (this is the standard format, the other being DSD). The SPDIF RCA and AES/EBU inputs handle up to 192 kHz / 24 bits, while Toslink optical inputs are limited to 96kHz.
We still don’t know what the HDMI input can handle.
I have heard the Weiss INT 202. Firewire is mostly a Mac world thing. The rest of the world uses Wintel PCs. I get sterling results from the jkeny-modified M2tech Hiface on a USB connection from foobar 2000 at a small fraction of the price of the Weiss. As Devialet suggests … use the M2tech Hiface USB / RCA sound interface. But get it from John Kenny, jkeny, as the mods make the HiFace a world beater.

Mr Plus -- Tue, 11/23/2010 - 16:40

Thanks for pointing this out. I've noticed my findings toward the analog inputs is far less severe than Paul Miller who reviewed an earlier version. I think all three of us are sort of right on this - it did resolve to 48kHz originally, subsequent models (including mine) resolve to 192/24 and this was disclosed on the FAQ recently. At the time of writing this review, the FAQ was TBA. Nevertheless, you are a lot 'righter' than I am on this one.

As to the AES/EBU processing up to 192kHz/24bit, the omission is all my fault, because of my antipathy toward hi-res source material. I am over-cautious of discussing hi-res in print because I've had people read that as implying it doesn't handle 44.1/16 files well. You are absolutely correct; the AES/EBU and S/PDIF can handle 192/24, while Toslink is limited to 96/24.

Devialet suggests both the Weiss and the M2tech solutions, depending on your computer options. I also suspect these are just the first of many such devices. To be perfectly honest, I used the D-Premier to very great effect at a demonstration in Manchester, England, simply running off iTunes with 16/44 ALAC through a Toslink cable and playing into a pair of Kiso HB-1 loudspeakers.

Alan Sircom
Editor, Hi-Fi Plus Magazine
London, England
editor [at] hifiplus [dot] com

curbfeeler -- Tue, 11/23/2010 - 21:25

Yes, I think you could get a fine result from the ALAC route you used. John Kenny is from your side of the pond, Ireland to be exact. Google jkeny. I would like you to hear what his mods do for the HiFace. You’d be doing your readers a service. Those who’ve heard my system lately say that I’m getting sound that rivals LP from my digital files nowadays.

gordon.edge1@bt... -- Wed, 11/24/2010 - 06:25

You can set the sampling rate from 48kHz to 192kHz via the config file. I initially had some problems at 96kHz with some anomalous signals probably caused by aliasing with my SACD player that were eliminated when the sampling rate was increased to 192kHz.

The amplifier is quite superb used with my QUAD 2905's easily outclassing my earlier Krell amps especially, but not only, at lower frequencies where the speaker impedance drops to circa 2 ohms. Interestingly the enhanced performance is obvious even to those without an interest in audio - a group of us meets regularly to listen to Opera and are very familiar with my system over a long time.

hltf -- Sat, 01/08/2011 - 20:31

Alan:
Where did you end up on the quality of the analog inputs? You suggested you were having second thoughts or doing an about face from the original comments in your review. I am wondering what to expect from my turntable and phonostage. Assuming I understand the unit's input options correctly, would you use the Devialet's phono input or your own phonostage sent to the Devialet's analog input? I am hoping to hear the unit soon.
Thank you
Hasan

Ron Lapporte -- Thu, 11/25/2010 - 14:46

Manufacturer's comment:

SlickenSmooth, thank you for considering Blue Smoke's Black Box for use with your Devialet D-Premier. We are confident that you will be very pleased should you decide to purchase one, as The Black Box was designed to be a single, uncompromised, audiophile, digital solution. Presently, we handle international sales directly, except for Hong Kong, where we have local distribution.

Interestingly, a number of our recent, and prospective customers, either own or are strongly considering the Devialet. We have yet to hear from anyone who is less than thrilled with the D-Premier, and we look forward to auditioning one ourselves in the near future.

Although we haven't had a chance to evaluate all of the USB/SPDIF converters and computer soundcards on the market, we have evaluated quite a large number of the devices commonly advocated by computer-savvy audiophiles. Our overall research findings are consistent with Paul Candy's of 6moons (http://www.6moons.com/audioreviews/m2tech/hiface.html), where during his very favorable review of the M2Tech hiFace, he noted that virtually any computer component, along with various settings dramatically affected sonic performance. Issues such as CPU overhead, codec selection (e.g. FLAC codecs sound very different from one to the next) USB vs. AES/EBU, operating system settings, etc., are all germane. In producing the Black Box, we took over two years developing our solution, taking everything into account in order to produce the cleanest, most audiophile-grade product possible.

Our goal was not to be the most cost-effective computer-based server design, but the finest sounding digital front-end available for consumer use. After evaluating many highly regarded off-the-shelf hardware and software systems, we were disappointed and concluded that in order to push the performance envelop we would have to develop own hardware and software solutions. Our custom software includes our Bit-Perfect Ripper (in order to get convenient perfect rips from our customer's CDs) and our tray app, which controls our unique hardware features such as internal/external clock selection, software/hardware-based upsampling, and auto sample-rate detection.

Our proprietary hardware was developed in conjunction with MSB Technology, a leader in audiophile-level digital technology. In addition to our extreme, ultra-low jitter spec (measured in trillionths of a second - as opposed to the standard billionths of a second [via SPDIF]) and 100% bit-perfect output through all the way to 24bit/192kHz, our solution includes both selectable hardware and/or software-based upsampling/downsampling - an industry exclusive! Our extensive interface selections include AES/EBU output, S/PDIF input/output, Toslink output, and the MSB network, an extremely high-quality I2S digital input/output (Over the MSB network, the jitter spec is reduced yet another order of magnitude to an almost immeasurable level). We have historically demonstrated the Black Box alongside an MSB DAC via the MSB network at CES.
The combination of the Black Box and MSB DAC is the preferred digital source for Rockport Technologies and was the front-end heart of the system that Robert Harley proclaimed to be "The best stereo system I've ever heard," after his visit to Rockport's facilities in Maine (http://www.avguide.com/blog/the-best-stereo-system-ive-ever-heard).

The synergy of the Black Box along with the MSB networked DAC is stunningly resolved and musically involving, providing yet another level of musical clarity. That said, many of our customers use other highly regarded DACs (e.g. Berkeley, BAlabo) and have achieved unprecedented sonic performance in their systems via AES/EBU and/or S/PDIF.

Although we won't be attending the upcoming CES, BAlabo will be including the Black Box as their digital front-end once again. They did not make this decision casually or without significant experience and evaluation of other digital solutions. Having spent some time with both their preamp and amplifier, I can unequivocally affirm the recent accolades bestowed by the Absolute Sound staff on these products. Their signature sound is simultaneously explosive and seductively glorious; a rare combination - conducive to endless musical enjoyment. BAlabo will be demonstrating on the 35th floor of the Venetian, along with newly upgraded Tidal speakers and Argento cables. I believe that BAlabo will provide a candid account of their experience with the Black Box supporting their DAC via a rather select S/PDIF cable. For those not planning to attend CES, they can be contacted through their website: www.balabo.com

Please feel free to write or call us with questions.
www.bluesmokesystems.com
(847) 977-0220

Ron Lapporte
Blue Smoke Entertainment Systems

All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1999 - 2011 NextScreen. All Rights Reserved.
Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.