Two Superb Surround Sound Front Ends, Compared
Home Theater/Multichannel Audio
Portable/PC Audio
TV / Displays
Two-Channel Audio
September 2nd, 2009 -- by Tom Martin
Source: Playback
Ratings (relative to comparably priced multichannel A/V controllers)
- Treble: 9.5
- Mids: 9.5
- Bass: 9
- Soundstaging: 9
- Dynamics: 9.5
- Resolution: 9.5
- Value: 10
FEATURES, Parasound Halo P7
- Subwoofer output with analog bass management
- Theater bypass mode to connect a digital surround receiver
- 2 sets of multichannel (7.1) inputs for surround sound movies & music
- 7 Stereo inputs; 1 balanced XLR input; 1 MM/MC phono input
- 7.1 channel balanced XLR outputs and unbalanced RCA outputs
- Custom input naming
- Source input level matching
- Defeatable tone controls
- Note: The Parasound Halo P7 is an analog audio-only preamplifier. As such, it does not provide onboard DACs, surround sound decoders, or video processors of any kind. Instead, it is targeted primarily toward purist multichannel audio enthusiasts.
FEATURES, Marantz AV8003
- 7.1-channel A/V pre-tuner with THX Ultra2 certification
- AV8003 can serve as an Ethernet-enabled, DLNA-compliant Digital Medial Player for audio, photo and video files (can access network attached devices, but cannot access the Internet directly).
- Sound processing modes: supports the latest HD audio codecs from Dolby (Dolby TrueHD), DTS (DTS-HD Master Audio), plus THX, Circle Surround, and Marantz’s proprietary M-DAX mode (intended to restore lost dynamics when playing MP3, or other compressed files).
- Two sets of 7.1-channel analog pre-amp outputs—one unbalanced (RCA), one balanced (XLR).
- Balanced (XLR) stereo analog input for use with high end CD or SACD player.
- Tuner: AM/FM/HD radio is standard, and AV8003 is both XM and Sirius satellite radio-ready.
- Ample analog and digital audio/video inputs and outputs (none on the front panel, however).
- HDMI 1.3A: four in, two out.
- Anchor Bay video scaling and processing: 10-bit video processing with upscaling to 1080p (but processing applies for SD sources only).
- Chassis is made of copper-plated heavy gauge steel to help minimize electrical noise and problems with physical vibrations.
- Multizone support, with component video output for remote zones.
- Comes with two remotes.
LISTENING EVALUATIONS, SONIC CHARACTER
Almost every test I’ve done offers up some surprises, and this one was no different. The first thing that confronted me was the similarity in sound between all four preamps. Since I’ve often had a strong preference for one preamp over another when doing testing, this similarity surprised me. Of course, each reviewer has a methodology, and I know I tend to look for tonal balance issues first. Maybe it isn’t too surprising that preamps, with their tendency to deliver superb measurements (flat frequency response, high channel separation, low noise, etc.), sound similar in this regard.
My next surprise, with more listening time, was how much the Parasound Halo P7 sounded like the superb conrad-johnson ART stereo preamp ($15,995 - discontinued) that I had on test last year. The P7 has a “golden” treble sound that I simply find beguiling. Treble sounds clear yet not etched or grainy. The decay of notes is well preserved, which is critical for soundstaging (space is recreated with very low level sounds). Bass is also very well produced, with impact and definition that rival any of the other preamps here. My listening notes refer to this as a “deserted island sound” meaning that it seems just the tiniest shade off of perfectly neutral, but in a way that lets the music shine through. You’d choose this kind of sound, I think, if you were living on a deserted island and had to choose your last preamp.
Comments
It is interesting--and telling--that the audio quality of well-made mid-market electronics (Marantz) is now equaling the higher-priced "purist" high-end products (Parasound)--and you get a lot more flexibility to boot. The idiosyncratic sound of the Audio Research is very troubling--if it sounds "different", I doubt that it can be better, since the principle of high fidelity performance is that all the competition should be sounding more similar the more accurate they become. If this trend continues (better quality mid-market products, escalating prices of high-end products), it simply won't be cost-effective to buy high-end products anymore except for the snob appeal.
Ron Levine
Philadelphia
Your comparisons echo the comments I made about the AV8003 on Amazon's web site yesterday. A friend of mine, after reading my comments, questioned whether or not I was being completely objective in my opinion that the analog section of the AV8003 is as good as those on some very high end 2-channel preamps that I've auditioned. I told him that absolute objectivity is difficult (as I own an AV8003) and that I might be justifiying my purchase in my own mind but that I felt I was being honest in my evaluation. Your article lends some credibility to my earlier assertion. I can hardly wait to hear his reaction to it.
I'm not sure how your unit was configured, but I've discovered that CD playback using the analogue out from either my Marantz DV9600 or Oppo BD83 and selecting Pure Direct mode on the AV8300 produces a sound that is hard to beat in my book.
Theoretically, a preamp should do nothing to the original signal other than possibly add some gain before sending it on to the amplifier so one would expect more similarities than differences amongst the various designs. Apparently, there is not a lot of differences in gain stages of preamps? The real differences in controllers become more apparent when they are performing D to A conversions, as there seems to be detectable differences in the various chipsets and implementations.
As a side note, I prefer the audio from theMarantz player over the Oppo in the described configuration although they both sound very good.
This is probably just my personal perception but when there is a review of something like a pre-amp it would seem nice to mention the amps that compliment or have been used to define these products along with any other equipment in the chain between the source and the listener? Did I miss this?
I wound up retunring two different P7s becasue they had an identical hashy noise coming from one channel from balanced outputs. Yes, I was careful to isolate it to the P7 by changing channel connectors from the sources and also to the amp. They were several hundred apart in serial number, so I wonder if this is some kind of weird problem they have. Was not present from the unbalanced outputs. Was quite evident from my high efficeincy Genesis speakers, but lower efficiency Soundlabs did not suffer to anywhere near the same degree.
I've owned the P7 for about 2 months, and have had the AV8003 for almost a week, with lots of listening hours on both. No conclusions yet, but did want to share that I initially heard the same sibilance referred to in the article ("emphasized the leading edge of treble sounds") in the P7. It was especially noticeable on the front edge of brass notes. All that said, it went away about a week or two. As an orchestral musical, I'm very fussy about accurate tonal quality, and I would have sent the unit right back had it not resolved.
If there’s interest, will post more after reaching conclusions.
This review was informative,but will there be a full review as a Surround sound processor?
I noticed the P7 has a phono preamp and the Marantz does not. Might make a difference to some.