Peachtree Audio iDecco Integrated Amp/USB DAC/iPod Dock (Playback 27)

The Coolest Integrated Amp/DAC/Dock Yet?

On the plus side of the ledger, the iDecco amp delivers a rich, clear, and evocative sound with excellent soundstaging characteristics. When coupled with speakers that can be driven well by 40 Wpc, the iDecco amp can produce huge, three-dimensional soundstages that leave the sound of many modestly priced integrated amps in the dust. During my tests, I used the iDecco in conjunction with a pair of Monitor Audio’s superb (and quite easy to drive) Silver RX8 floorstanders ($2000/pair) and found the combination to be one of those rare instances of “sonic serendipity” where the whole was much greater than the sum of the parts. Think of it this way: you could buy an iDecco and the Monitor Audio speakers I mentioned above for about $3000, then add either a PC-based music server and/or an iPod as source components, acquire an obligatory set of high performance cables, and wind up with a music system that—I kid you not—could easily do battle with many of the five-figure systems I’ve heard at trade shows.

Good though the iDecco amplifier section is, however, I would say it is perhaps not quite as impressive as other elements of the product are. The main sonic differences you would observe between the iDecco amp and higher end powerplants (such as the NuForce monoblocks I used in my tests) involve the iDecco’s slightly reduced levels of resolution and detail from top to bottom and somewhat less tightly controlled and less deeply extended bass response. There is, too, a difference in sheer power output to be reckoned with (remember, the iDecco produces an honest 40 Wpc at 6 ohms, while the NuForce monoblocks each belt out 335 watts at 4 ohms). In practice, this means you’ll want to keep the iDecco’s power output limitations in mind and plan your speaker acquisitions accordingly.

But let’s keep things in perspective. While the iDecco’s amp section may not enjoy the quasi-giant-killer status that its DAC and preamp sections do, it nevertheless offers very solid performance and—more importantly—unfailing musicality for the money.

 

MUSICAL EXAMPLES

I can’t speak for you, but I sometimes enjoy playing well-made recordings that show unexpected combinations of instruments at play, partly because they draw your attention to the musical ideas being expressed, but also because they seem like celebrations of the sheer beauty of sound, itself. One such recording is Marilyn Mazur and Jan Garbarek’s Elixir [ECM], where two favorite tracks are “Bell-Painting” and “Talking Wind.” Both tracks employ distinctive high percussion instruments of various kinds, highlighting differences in the attack, voicing, and decay characteristic of each instrument as played within a reverberant recording space. On good equipment, the sonic effect of hearing these tracks is not unlike running your fingers through a treasure chest full of variegated jewels—so many different shapes, textures and colors to take in at once. On both tracks the iDecco not only did not disappoint, but positively excelled.

On “Bell-Painting,” the shorter and more delicate of the two musical selections, you initially hear a round of differently pitched small bells and chimes being struck, followed by a similar round of slightly deeper-pitched bells and gongs being sounded. The iDecco deftly captured the variations in attack between the bells, appropriately giving each its signature voice, and showing how decay characteristics help define the bells’ sound—with some fading quickly to silence as others continue to shimmer and ring for several seconds after being struck, their voices lingering and floating on the air. Most importantly, the iDecco captured—but did not overdo—the fundamentally metallic character of the bells, something that in practice is easier to say than to do on this revealing track (some amps, for example, make the instruments sound much too "dry," almost like bursts of white noise, which isn't right). The iDecco served up levels of realism and nuance that not many amp/DACs in its price range could muster.

Comments

Andrew in Brisbane (not verified) -- Thu, 02/11/2010 - 17:00

I'm an early adopter. When I put my iPod 120Gb classic in the dock, I expected (and got) something that sounded like the real thing. Most of the fatiguing "stuff" I couldn't quantify or describe was gone. And that's why this is really something special - so much MUSIC for so little money.

However the real revelation was pulling digital direct from my (heavily modded) Oppo DV-981HD, which has a very expensive DAC. The iDecco simply blew it away and I agree with your conclusion that the DAC is worth the price all by itself. It also made me realise the Rip->EAC->Convert to Apple Lossless v putting the CD in the tray is a bit overblown. I was very (very!) hard pressed to tell the difference between the carefully ripped and carelessly played CD.

The final selling point about this - which you reviewers in your fabulous audio rooms may not appreciate :) - is the WAF...

Lindsey Topper (not verified) -- Wed, 06/09/2010 - 14:55

I like the IDecco. I use it with NHT powered speakers and powered subwoofer. The preamp stage and dac are terrific. The V-DAC and V-Can which cost approximately $500.00 together would be a great USB DAC and Amp for headphones only. The V-Can (headphone amp) has a pass through which would allow you to use the V-DAC as a Dac for headphones or speakers using a Wadia/Ipod or computer as the music
source.

IDecco has a good headphone amp with DAC and Ipod transport. The V-can and V-dac has more balls to run your AKG 701/702 headphones. If you add high quality wiring from Wadia transport to dac to headphone amp, add another $100.00 for a total of $600.00. The WAdia transport is $379.00. In essence, the IDecco is probably the better deal. All you need is speaker cable. The headphone section is not as powerful as the V-Can/V-Dac combo.

vincent - sydneysider (not verified) -- Fri, 02/12/2010 - 07:16

My iDecco arrived in m Sydney office Monday 8 Feb and I having read the manufacturers advice I have really just had it warming up till today. This is my new CBD office system and improvement in music quality (compared to my prior system of ipod line out dock into a good amp) is immediately obvious. Users should buy with confidence about the sonic quality. Wife does not yet know but yes I agree it would get a goof WAF rating.

Vincent

Chris Martens -- Fri, 02/12/2010 - 13:08

Alex,

At the moment, Playback's review samples of the AKG K702s are in Tom Martin's possession. If I can carve out some spare time to do so, I will either borrow the K702s from Tom or loan the iDecco to him so we can supply some follow-up comments.

In my own tests, I used the iDecco with Shure SRH840 and Denon A-HD5000 headphones with excellent results. Not surprisingly, the sound qualities of the iDecco-as-headphone amp closely mirrored those that I observed when evaluating the iDecco-as-preamp, which is why I let one set of comments stand for both applications.

Best, Chris Martens

Chris Martens
Editor, Avguide.com/Playback/The Perfect Vision 

Andrew from Brisbane (not verified) -- Mon, 02/15/2010 - 16:45

The iDecco as a headphone amp - US$79 for a pair of RE0s is another almost unbelievable bargain!

Alex30 (not verified) -- Wed, 03/24/2010 - 04:02

Thanks for your reply Chris,
Has there been any progress on the capabilities of the iDecco with the AKG K 702's ? Also can you confirm if the Decco 2 is the same as the iDecco but without the ipod docking facility ? Also am I right in thinking that the Decco 2 and the iDecco share the same DAC and headphone amp as the Nova ?
Regards Alex

Chris Martens -- Tue, 07/27/2010 - 18:03

Alex 30,

I (eventually) got a chance to try the iDecco with the AKG K702 and I would say that while the results were not horrible, neither were they great. For whatever reason, the iDecco did not seem to make a happy match with the K702 (or vice versa?) so that the resulting sound seemed somewhat "compressed" and "lifeless" to me (this in sharp contrast to the much, much better results I achieved when using the iDecco with other headphones such as the Shure SRH840).

My thought: I feel confident that there are other headphone amps that would work better with the K702s (or to turn things around, other headphones that would work better with the iDecco).

The iDecco uses a different tube than the Nova, so to that extent the headphone amps of the iDecco and Nova are similar but not exactly "the same."

My understanding is that the iDecco and Nova share the same fundamental DAC sections, though the mix of available inputs is of course quite different between the two.

Chris Martens
Editor, Avguide.com/Playback/The Perfect Vision 

a_d_a_m_s -- Thu, 01/06/2011 - 14:47

Dear Sirs,
I've read the favorable reviews for iDecco and decided to consider it as a component to build my small system upon. Thus I decided to ask you about your experience of what could be the best match for it? I see it has rather limited power so should be used in small areas which is fine with me as I have around 15-20 sq meters room where I would plan to make a computer based and/or Ipod based system. Do I get it right that I can connect iDecco via USB to an ordinary soundcard and it will substitute its DAC and thus all sound processing will go through iDecco and all I need is a pair of nicely matching speakers? If yes, what should be the best suitable speakers in your opnion (cost-effective off course as the budget is quite limited). If I still would need some external soundcard as a medium between my notebook and iDecco, what should it be as a soundcard? Thank you in advance for your opinions and any replies.

With kind regards,
Alexey

a_d_a_m_s -- Thu, 01/06/2011 - 14:56

found the suggested monitors, sorry. now only the question regarding the soundcard. And maybe the cables? thank you!

sperandeo -- Sun, 03/20/2011 - 21:27

I have had the iDecco for some time and it sounded nice. A friend of mine suggested I try a pair of Blessed Cables with it. I ordered a pair online and they have improved the sound of the iDecco by 100%. The Blessed OMH1 cable made everything smoother and richer. They are spectacular.
www.blessedcables.com

All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1999 - 2011 NextScreen. All Rights Reserved.
Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.