Magnepan Mini Maggie Desktop Speaker System (Playback 48)

The World’s Best Desktop Speaker System

I’ve just heard something extraordinary: namely Magnepan’s three-piece Mini Maggie desktop speaker system ($1490), which I feel confident in describing as the best system of its kind in the known world. These are strong words, to be sure, but words that in this case are more than justified by this compact system’s jaw-droppingly terrific performance. In the course of this review, I’ll discuss the Mini Maggie system’s sound in some detail, but before I do, some background information is in order.

The Mini Maggie system consists of three elements: a pair of true ribbon/planar magnetic dipole desktop panels and a matching Magnepan DWM planar magnetic dipole woofer module, which is designed to fit neatly within the knee hole space of a typical desk. The crossover network for the system is housed within the woofer module, so that you would run speaker cables from your amplifier to the woofer, and then run shorter supplemental speaker cables from the woofer up to the two desktop modules—all very simple, elegant, and more or less foolproof. Once you get the system wired up and begin to play music, it’s pretty much time to fasten your figurative seatbelts, because you will be treated—assuming your amp and source components are up to the task—to sound that not only sets a world-class standard for desktop audio, but comes very close to matching world class standards for hi-fi systems of any kind.

Let me also provide a few words of explanation and introduction for those of you who have never seen or experienced Magnepan loudspeakers of any kind. All of Magnepan’s loudspeakers, regardless of size, use planar magnetic drivers and are dipole radiators (meaning they radiate sound to the front and to the rear, but have a distinctive dispersion pattern that, if viewed from directly above the speaker, would resemble a “figure 8”). There are several implications of using this sort of configuration.

First, Magnepan speakers do not have (or need) box-type enclosures of any kind, and second, Magnepans do not use traditional piston-type drive units with cone or dome-shaped diaphragms. Instead, Magnepan speakers have relatively large, rectangular, membrane-like diaphragms with conductors (either wires or quasi-ribbons) bonded in a specific pattern over the diaphragm’s surface. The diaphragms, in turn, are mounted in a minimalist perimeter frame (remember, there are no boxes here) and suspended in front of an open-mesh metal panel to which are attached slender arrays of bar-type magnets, also arranged in a specific pattern. When audio signals pass through the conductors on the diaphragm, they interact with the fields from the magnets causing the entire diaphragm surface to be pulled toward or pushed away from the magnet array, thus producing sound.

In Magnepan’s most sophisticated speakers (including the Mini Maggie systems), tweeter assemblies use what the firm terms “true ribbon”-type drivers, which offer another variation on planar magnetic driver technology. Instead of having conductors bonded to an underlying plastic membrane, ribbon drivers use an ultra-thin, corrugated “ribbon” of aluminum in a dual-purpose role, serving as both the conductor and as the diaphragm at the same time. The result is a driver whose sole moving element is quite literally lighter than the air it is moving, which means the driver can be incredibly responsive and offers almost incomprehensibly quick transient response.

One final configuration note is that Magnepan speakers are typically fairly large in frontal area, but are very thin—just 1.25 inches thick! For listeners who have played with Magnepan speakers the ultra-thin design seems perfectly normal, but it can be a bit mind-bending, at least at first, for those who have known nothing but box-type loudspeakers in the past. But after a few minutes of listening, many first-timers concede that “Maggies” neither look nor sound like box speakers, noting with delight that they offer important elements of sonic realism few box speakers can match.

FEATURES

Magnepan Mini Maggie desktop panels:

• Mini Maggie desktop panels feature planar magnetic midrange drivers and true ribbon tweeters whose design is a miniature version of the tweeter used in the firm’s top tier 3.7 and 20.1 floorstanding loudspeakers.
• Desktop panels are each a bit larger than a typical notebook in frontal area (14” high x 9.5” wide), but are—as mentioned above—just 1.25” in depth or thickness.
• The panels come with elliptical pedestal-like desktop stands and are offered with either natural or black-finished solid oak or dark cherry trim and fabric grilles produced in black, grey, or off-white.

Comments

jimmyjames -- Thu, 09/08/2011 - 11:18

Going to need a lot of desk top and open real estate around this 2.1 system. I'll just stick to my Harbeth PS3's. FWIW...I was a Maggie owner for 20+ years thru 3 different models. Great speakers in the right (big) room.

ldevoe -- Thu, 09/08/2011 - 12:31

Review sounds very promising. What electronics did you use to drive them? Did you play computer-stored files? While the price might seem a bit high, for those of us who spend a considerable time with our desktop computers, these speakers could make the experience much more enjoyable.

Jimbo Jim FB -- Thu, 09/08/2011 - 12:53

i bought a few of these Monsoons, at 15 bills is sure hard to put them on your desk, mind as well put $ into the big system, be honest when u really working do u need such a good system?
I find I cant enjoy the music at work only use them to avoid quietness, whilst at home I put away worries any really enjoy!
Then again for the Nouveau riche u need name brand and top of the line thing to aggravate your friends though.
Maggies were also know to be real pigs for power, I had a pair of SMG circa 80s. They're nice but bass kind of lacking then.

fanboy@rcn.com -- Thu, 09/08/2011 - 12:58

Sounds like [well, reads like but yaknow what I mean] this desktop system would similarly perform exceedingly well with a freestanding [not wall mounted] HDTV and give accompanying audio justice to a brilliant video picture. Think it will work with the L & R speakers on pedestals?

Josh Hill -- Sat, 09/10/2011 - 17:19

The word from Magnepan is that they can be used on stands, but while they've found that they can work surprisingly well as woofer/satellite systems in small rooms, they were designed primarily as near field speakers and they don't really know yet how they'll work out in a range of applications. So they're recommending that if you want to try this, you work out some kind of arrangement with your dealer, because they don't want customers to be disappointed after buying them for an application for which they weren't designed. Also, they say that there are some forthcoming reviews that try them in a woofer/satellite configuration, so you may want to wait for those.

My personal take on it is that it makes sense to wait until there's been more field experience and reviews. Wendell Diller of Magnepan says some reviews are coming that try them in a woofer/satellite configuration.

mrbrogan97@gmail.com -- Thu, 09/08/2011 - 15:03

What amplifier(s) and source components did you use in this test?

Donkeyshins -- Thu, 09/08/2011 - 23:47

The Monsoon brand computer desktop planar speakers + subwoofer go back to 2000-2001 and were developed by Bruce Thigpen of Eminent Technology (based on original multimedia computer speakers from 1995). I'd love to see you do a comparison between the two systems (although the Monsoon would be at a disadvantage since it used a BASH amplifier for the sub & satellites).

Josh Hill -- Fri, 09/09/2011 - 16:29

I have and love the Monsoons, but I doubt they're in the same league as the Mini Maggies -- no ribbon tweeter, and a ported (or in my 2000's passive radiator) woofer rather than the planar woofer on the Mini-Maggies. Of course, they cost only $200, as opposed $1500, so I wouldn't expect them to. Eminent did sell a higher-end computer speaker for $500, AFAIK they aren't made anymore.

rick996r -- Sat, 09/10/2011 - 16:21

I have the Harbeth P3ESR's on my desk with a full NuForce system/DAC running off my MacBook Pro and can't wait to get the Mini Maggie system, it sounds like a new advance for near field listening, which I enjoy immensely. Great review Chris, thanks

imickey503@gmail.com -- Sun, 09/11/2011 - 22:22

But I wonder what the DAW market is going to do with these. I like the fact that the speakers are claiming to be the worlds best.

Josh Hill -- Mon, 09/12/2011 - 10:29

I was wondering the same thing.

mutyangparol -- Mon, 09/12/2011 - 18:37

I've read all the glowing reviews of nearly all of Magnepan's loudspeakers. I've never owned one but I'm seriously considering it now. My only reservation is in the areas of dynamics and dynamic contrast. Lets take the Maggie Pups or Minis for example. In a small room would it really beat conventional design from the likes of say Proac Response, Totem, Sonus Faber, Dynaudio, etc. in the areas mentioned (i.e. dynamics and dynamic contrast) ? Thanks in advance.

Josh Hill -- Mon, 09/12/2011 - 19:08

Not in dynamics. Of course, this depends on the model -- a big Maggie model will outpunch a small dynamic speaker. But dynamics and bass extension are the two areas in which conventional speakers tend to have an advantage over planars.

Bass extension of course can be extended with a sub, so I don't think it's that significant a limitation.

mutyangparol -- Mon, 12/12/2011 - 02:07

Thanks Josh. WIll planars fry or suffer permanent damage if played loud on highly dynamic material like movies with explosions and gunshots?

Josh Hill -- Tue, 01/17/2012 - 13:02

Not Maggies, generally the worst that will happen is that the woofer diaphragm will slap the magnets (loud sound but no harm) or the tweeter fuse will blow. It's possible to damage the true ribbon in the most expensive Maggie models (3.7 and 20.7) with amplifier clipping, apparently the speaker fuse doesn't always get that. But for that reason, the true ribbons are designed to be easily replaced and from what I've seen it isn't a problem unless something goes wrong (e.g., clipping). Normally the fuse will go first. Of greater concern I think for movie use is that if you really push explosions and stuff you'll bottom out the woofer, which as I said doesn't sound good. I think for movies, you generally want to use Maggies with a dynamic sub. You can switch it out of the path for music if you find that it colors the sound (it isn't easy to find a sub that matches the clarity of planar bass -- in general, sealed subs are better than ported, and subs designed for music reproduction rather than movies). One possibility is to use the sub in the bottom octave for music and with a higher crossover for movies. It's hard to generalize here since the larger the planar, the more bass it produces on its own, generally each model will have 5 Hz more of bass extension but more important than that more slam. I used to use my Tympanis, which have huge woofers, on movies all the time and they were just great, I didn't want a sub.

So I wouldn't worry about the robustness of the planars any more than I would the robustness of dynamic speakers, the real concern here is whether a give model plays loud enough or low enough for your needs.

MrAcoustat -- Wed, 12/19/2012 - 06:50

Sorry but if you compare DOLLAR FOR DOLLAR nothing play's like a panel, you may not get BIG BOOMY BASS but you will get real true bass panels have enough bass for 95% of audiophiles whe are sorry for the other 5% ( Peter Walker Quad )

All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1999 - 2011 NextScreen. All Rights Reserved.
Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.