Magico Q5 loudspeaker (Hi-Fi+ 74)

Installation is easy… just get someone else to do it! No, really – the speakers weigh enough that moving them to get good positioning isn’t really an option, so it’s better to get a team of experts to move and install the speakers. While it’s probably somewhat impolitic to mention this, the best way of installing these speakers is ‘vowelling in’, a method of installation developed by Wilson Audio (it’s also known as ‘voicing the room’ or simply WASP: Wilson Audio Set-up Proceedure). This works by speaking to the rear and side walls at the point where the speaker would likely end up. At first, your voice sounds artificially chesty and thick due to boundary interaction. Mark where that point begins, and keep walking until your voice begins to sound thin and hollow. Do the same with the side wall and do the same to for the other speaker. Make an half-inch grid within these parameters and adjust the speakers for the best possible bass in the room, from the listening position. This gets less easy to do when you have a loudspeaker weighing in at close to 180kg per speaker (that’s almost 400lb, or nearly 28st), so call in expert help.

The Magico needs that millimetre-tight installation precision – and necessitates good quality audio equipment feeding it – because it can give so much. The amplifiers need to be as quick as they are powerful when it comes to driving this. This is why successful partnerships are to be found in products from the Spectral and especially the DarTZeel range, but it was also more than comfy with the excellent Devialet D-Premier category-busting integrated power DAC. Of course, bolted on the end of nigh on £150,000 worth of DarTZeel monos, you’d expect something special. What you get a sound so dynamically unfettered that you expect to catch a cone or two as they go whizzing past your ears. This comes with a warning – do not play chicken with an amp that can go from zero to 1.5kW in an eyeblink and a speaker that can handle that sort of wallop; eventually something will give, but it’s more likely to be you than the amp or speaker. I have heard a drive unit get fried this way, but only trying to recreate the sound and sound pressure of rock concerts that gave half the audience tinnitus. Otherwise, these speakers are fundamentally unburstable. I know… I tried and it hurts.

It’s easy to lose the message in the medium when it comes to hi-fi and high-end in particular. We’ve become so used to having sounds with a distinct tonal balance, that when you hear something that’s inherently flat, it can sound ‘flat’. We struggle to get past remarkable flatness of frequency response, because it’s not something we are used to outside of live events with unamplified instruments. So, at first flush the Q5 will sound laid back to some, edgy to others. The reality is, those first impressions don’t count, because they are tempered by our preconceptions and the albums played there.

A sure sign of that Q standing for ‘Quality’ comes in the Q5’s shape-shifting qualities. It’s as good as your discs, and no better. That sounds like damning it with faint praise, but is the key to quality. Swap from The Fall to Charles Mingus and there should be a huge change in recording quality; different production values, studios, engineers, musicians and mastering. That disc-to-disc differentiation stands out with uncanny clarity here.

The other side to this is plain; don’t go expecting the Q5 to make a silk purse out of a Lady Gaga album. If it sounds congested, constricted, forward or laid back in the recording, the Q5 will make that apparent. This will mean some of your hitherto ‘wonder’ recordings will sound less ‘wonderful’ than you originally thought. And yet, curiously, this honesty doesn’t get in the way of the musical content. That’s the joy of really, really honest loudspeakers; you get to listen through the recording chain. It sounds like nothing is acting as impediment. Of course, when you get the really, really good recordings that happen to be musically significant too… then you start to see why music is such a vital aspect of so many people’s lives.

Here’s a perfect example. Among the line-up of recordings played, I pulled out the MoFi version of Dixie Chicken by Little Feat. I’ve heard this recording hundreds of times over the years; it’s one of those albums – like Dylan’s Desire and Traffic’s Shoot Out at the Fantasy Factory – that keep cropping up in my life. It’s rare to have that album to have the same affect it had when I first heard it almost 30 years ago round at the parents of a very cool hippy chick artsy girl, who I was sort of dating at the time. A combination of teenage-grade hormones and copious amounts of claret made that a monumental event, despite my complete failure to get anywhere monumental with said hippy chick artsy girl. No subsequent replay of that album can match the weighting of that first listen, but the Q5 gets as close enough to conjure up the heady mix of white musk and patchouli oil.

Comments

bherlihy -- Wed, 08/18/2010 - 10:07

Hi Alan - i mentioned to you on Whatsbestforum that i just took delivery and saw your comment there, i didn't realize you were reviewing them at this time. i am really excited to hear them (still finishing renovations, but should be only a few more weeks now). can you tell me what cabling and other components you used. btw - i had to hire a crane to get the speakers into my four story walk up. i will be working with Rives to do the placement - hope they bring some strong guys.

pal1 -- Sat, 10/09/2010 - 09:06

I am so tired of your publications so often declaring a new product as subjective as audio equipment being "The Best". Don't you think that this could be damaging to your credibility when a month later a new "best" is declared? As far as Magico M5 owners not caring about the value of their recently purchased $90,000.00 speakers now being worth a third of that because " they were too busy enjoying their speakers to notice"........ give me a break! If I owned M5's I'd be camping out at Magico's front door demanding a full refund.

chrisheinonen -- Sat, 10/09/2010 - 16:55

Often those comments that you are referring to are written as "The best that I have heard", not that the product is the end all for all products, but just that this reviewer has heard. The writer of the recent Vandersteen 7 review is different than this review, so both can say that what they have reviewed is the best that they have heard, and next month I'm sure another writer could say that something else is the best that they have heard. Additionally, I think most readers focus on the details more than the summary at the end, as I know I do since what one person thinks is the best might not be the best to me, and reading the review will give me the details on why that may or may not be the case.

Sam -- Mon, 10/11/2010 - 15:11

But the M5's were reviewed by JV and the Q5 pre-review is also by JV that clearly states how much better and cheaper the Q5 is from M5. And all of this within a year. I think while all this was in the works I am sure Magico knew about the upcoming product. They didn't create the Q5 in a few months(my logical guess). In an ideal world Magico could have been fourthcoming of an upcoming Q5 and maybe issued the M5 as a special edition product??? I don't know.... but its a tough call...technology and things improve....Q5 and M5 have different designs and it would be difficult to predict before one was produced if one would surpass the other. Also magicos claim that the Q is cheaper because of production costs and inhouse machienes that they just bought would most likely be true. As one of the hottest company in the market right now they have to make profit too. We live in a free market. People can charge what ever the customer will cough up.

SundayNiagara -- Sat, 10/09/2010 - 20:29

"give me a break! If I owned M5's I'd be camping out at Magico's front door demanding a full refund."

Post of the year!

Mr Plus -- Tue, 10/12/2010 - 18:19

As this is the first time - to my knowledge - that I have made that unqualified 'the best' statement in 20 years of reviewing, I think my credibility is intact, thanks very much.

And as to those M5 owners camping out at Magico's front door, there's a little matter of this not actually happening that gets in the way of your argument and sort of reinforces my suggestion that the only people getting hot under the collar about this are the sententious non-M5 owners.

Alan Sircom
Editor, Hi-Fi Plus Magazine
London, England
editor [at] hifiplus [dot] com

pal1 -- Wed, 10/13/2010 - 18:04

Mr. Sircom,

I did not mean to insinuate that you have lost your credibility. I just think that as an editor of a well respected audio magazine it is dangerous to declare a piece of audio equipment as "the best". There is no such thing.

As far as the Magico M5 situation, maybe the current owners of these spaekers aren't concerned about their plummeting value due to the introduction in a relatively short time by Magico of a new and apparently better less expensive speaker. Magico ought to cherish customers like these.

All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1999 - 2011 NextScreen. All Rights Reserved.
Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.