Accustic Arts Drive I Mk 2 and DAC I Mk IV

Accustic Arts is a poorly spelled but very well made audio range from Germany. In addition to the Drive I Mk 2 CD transport and DAC I Mk 4 converter, the brand has an integrated amp, a pre-amp and three power amps, a CD and universal player and – most recently – a reference class valve DAC. There are speakers and a range of accessories, too. The products have a consistent theme: a very clean sound and build quality second to none. And yet, the products are little-known, even among high-end enthusiasts – I suspect there might be some anti-Euro xenophobia at play. If these two products had a big British or American name on the front panel, they’d be on every audiophile’s Most Wanted list. Or maybe it’s just a very contended market. Whatever the reason, this particular transport and DAC combo deserve more recognition, because they work particularly well. Both in combination or taken on their own.

One of the biggest bonuses of the transport mechanism in the £2,895 Drive I Mk 2 CD transport is that it is perhaps the quietest we’ve ever (not) heard. Once you close that thick shiny cover on the top of the player, having put the mag-puck over the spindle of the disc, you won’t hear a thing, even if you stick your ear to the side of the transport. You can barely even feel the vibration. Of course, the toploading mech – a Philips CDM Pro 2 LF; good, hardcore stock built on a mechanically decoupled cast metal chassis – does mean the player makes crucial demands on placement. You must position this on the top shelf of the rack, because not only is the transport set back from the front panel, but it’s also got an inch-high knob on the lid of the transport (and it’s not powered).

Inside the thick chassis is the sort of solid engineering you would expect to find inside an amplifier (or possibly a Naim CD player), with a heavily shielded 75VA toroidal transformer and 45,000μF of smoothing capacitance. The player has no less than four separate power supply stages, feeding drive, DSP, display control and display heating stages. A brace of transformer-coupled coaxial phono, BNC and balanced AES/EBU XLR connections form the sockets on the back panel of this heavy aluminium chassis.

There is a touch of bling about both transport and DAC. The transport has a blue glowing logo on the sliding draw – this can be defeated, but is bright enough to light up a small room. Then there’s the overall look, with brushed aluminium cases with shiny chrome knobs. This stays just the right side of garish… but only just. In contrast, the old school Philips display is understated, but not the most informative around.

The DAC is styled similarly to the transport. It has a pair of big shiny knobs (gratuitous on a DAC, surely) and three indicator LEDs in between. It’s a multi-bit affair, but uniquely works to 66-bit precision and 1.536GHz sampling. This comes from using a pair of multi-channel DAC chips parallel-connected for fully balanced operation. That said, we preferred the sound of the Drive to DAC through the single-ended BNC connection with analogue output in balanced. With four XLR inputs, two phonos and a BNC connector, plus both XLR and phono output, you have room to experiment. There is also an unbalanced version, that shaves £200 off the base £3,100 price. The DAC I Mk 4 also sports a high-grade filter stage, with 60,000μF of Panasonic filtration and a Class A output that’s claimed to be nabbed from the pro studio world. Once again, a toroidal transformer – a 100VA model – provides the motive power.

Normally when checking out combinations of CD transport and DAC (or pre-amp and power amp for that matter), one side is better than the other. It’s rare to find a matched pair, but the Accustic Arts duo are just that. Yes, the transport is also a perfect partner for the company’s Reference converter and if you upgraded the transport, you’d still be able to squeeze out better performance from the DAC I Mk 4, but the two go together perfectly. So well, in fact, it’s a shame to break them up.

The drive is a timing hound. It adds a degree of precision to the sound of the digital output that is exceptionally hard to find elsewhere; not just in tempo like an old Linn turntable, but spatial and temporal precision. Sounds have a tangible ‘space’ in the soundstage and hang together beautifully, eliminating some of the artifice of the replay chain in the process.

Moving over to the DAC, it’s a minor revelation. Music here seems fundamentally ‘right’ through the partnership. It’s difficult to pin down, because – like the very best products – it seems to do little more than the merely good kit, but that last degree of ‘rightness’ to the sound is what separates the Wadias and Zandens from the rest.

Comments

carlofromitaly (not verified) -- Mon, 04/26/2010 - 17:44

I have just carried out a listening test of the Accustic Arts DAC1 Mk4

Test conditions

The AA DAC1 Mk4 was extensively tested against an Audio Research DAC3 MkII equipped with Philips Miniwatt tubes; digital sources were a CD Transport TEAC P-30 and several FLAC files 16bit/44KHz stored in the hard disk of an HP Compaq nc8430 notebook equipped with Foobar2000 software and connected to the DAC via M2Tech-Hiface device and RCA/SPDIF Van Den Hul M.C. DigiCoupler 75 Ohm cable. A few tests were conducted comparing digital sound to vinyl.

Test Rig

Acoustic Signature Analog One MkII turntable
SME V tonearm + Van Den Hul Grasshopper III CHA MC pickup
Audio Research PH-7 pre phono
Audio Tekne TFM 8904 PCS integrated amplifier
Modified Klipschorn speakers equipped with ALK Trachorn 400 on K55 transducer + Beyma CP-25 horn tweeter and ALK Engineering AP12-AK3 + ES5800 crossover
Audio Tekne signal and power wiring

Software

Clayton Brothers – Back in the swing of things (CD and files FLAC 16/44)
Carol Kidd – Debut (CD and files FLAC 16/44)
Patricia Barber – Modern Cool (CD and files FLAC 16/44)
Patricia Barber – A forthnight in France (CD and vinyl LP)
Hugh Masekela – Hope (CD and vinyl LP)
Norah Jones – Come away with me (CD and vinyl LP)
Bill Evans Trio – I will say goodbye (CD and vinyl LP)
Yamamoto Tsuyoshi trio - Midnight Sugar (CD and vinyl LP)
Chet Baker – Chet (CD and vinyl LP)
Eric Clapton – Unplugged (CD and vinyl LP)

How it sounds

The AA DAC sounds much better than the ARC DAC3 as expected; it provides a transparent and rich sound while it maintanis the same sort of timber as the ARC. The soundstage is clearly more focused, wider and deeper, the holografic image is more realistic and there is more information in the background (echoes, ambience, instrument sound tail..). Notwithstanding its ability to read the smallest nuances, the AA DAC provides a pleasant sound without any sense of harshness or granulosity.

Nevertheless, you can still feel that sort of CD feeling as the music comes out a little bit flattened and somehow missing some bits, just to confirm the limitations of such support. Switching to the FLAC files there is an obvious difference in quality especially when using the AA DAC thanks to its stronger resolving power.

As the ARC DAC3 only accepts redbook sampling rates I only used 16/44 files however could clearly notice some improvements on the high frequency spectrum, on the amount of information and generally speaking, on the overall musical reproduction now closer to the real thing. This improvement is much more evident for the AA DAC. No doubts that the future of hi-end is in the PC music.

At this point I would like to mention the listening test I did comparing CD to vinyl. Two different worlds I’m afraid. The rithm, the musicality and the realism of a soundstage produced by a good vinyl record are still out of rich. However I mus say that when I threw some high resolution files (24/96 and 24/192 FLAC files) into the AA DAC, the results were extraordinary. Unfortunately I didn’t have CD or vinyl copies of such files to compare with, but I am safe to assess that these results come very close to best vinyl printed from digital masters altough I’m still reluctanto to assess the same in case of vinyl printed from analog masters.

Conclusion

To my opinion the AA is a very good DAC with top class performance and solid build but with a couple of small bugs, at least in my rig: the level of output signal is slightly low for my amplifier, the soudstage is laid back although deep and wide and finally, the music misses just a bit of ‘verve’ at least for my taste

All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1999 - 2011 NextScreen. All Rights Reserved.
Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.