Although I am interested in acquiring a Blu-Ray player at some point now that the Hi-Def video format war is over, I don’t have a single BD-DVD at the moment… and I do have several hundred standard def DVD’s. Therefore, I want a machine that will up-convert my SD-DVD’s to HD with the highest possible video quality. I need a player that will output both 720p and 1080p in top quality. My current projector – a Panasonic AE700U – tops out at 720p, but I’ll be picking up a newer projector later this year.
Additionally, I don’t have a need for DVD-A or SACD, so I’m not worried about that capability. I have around a thousand Redbood CD’s, and an incredible sounding transport/DAC combination I’m very happy with, so I’ve just never purchased any of the “higher definition” audio disks.
So, the question is this… Does the Oppo 980 play up-converted standard DVD’s with a better PQ than the Panny BD30? Or the other way around?
I could save a few dollars overall if I was able to just buy the BD30 and be done with it. But if the PQ of the Oppo would be significantly better when up-converting SD-DVD’s, then I’ll get an Oppo now, and pick up a Blu-Ray player down the road when BD-DVD’s prices become more realistic.
Feedback from anyone that has direct experience with both the Oppo and Panasonic players would be greatly appreciated.
This doesn't address the Panasonic comparison, but may be useful if you haven't seen it:
http://magazine.playbackmag.net/playback/200801web/
The Oppo review starts on page 97, and an interesting chart is on page 206
Hope that helps a bit, though I wonder if the upconversion in your new projector might not be the way to go.
I've done many of the Oppo reviews for The Absolute Sound and Playback/TPV and felt I should mention that, in terms of pure video performance, the Oppo DV-981HD is arguably superior to the DV-980H (though on real world material, as opposed to benchmark discs, the differences tend to be pretty subtle).
But the best Oppo video performer of all will likely be the new DV-983H, which I'm in the process of testing now. I'll let you know how the tests turn out.
I've not had a chance to compare the Oppos vs. 2nd or 3rd-generation BD players yet, so I can't comment in that area just yet.
Chris Martens
Editor, Avguide.com/Playback/The Perfect Vision