Do CD-R's sound better?

EasyBigFella -- Mon, 01/28/2008 - 14:08

I was re-reading Robert Harley's article about why perhaps hard disks are better data sources (with music) than disc transports. I think that RH made a solid case and his reasoning is sound. What I mainly inferred from the article is that bit errors are virtually non-existent, and that differences in sound quality on the digital side of a source (transport -> clock) are overwhelmingly determined by jitter (timing error). However, the mention of CD-R's superiority continues to perplex me. I believe that it's plausible that they do sound better, but the exact reasons why still elude me.

If CD-R's sound better, is there any research that demonstrates lower timing error between a Red Book disc and its CD-R duplicate? The difference between a CD and a CD-R is that the reflected laser light scatters much more with a commercially-manufactured disc than with a CD-R because of the physical deviations between land and pit. A CD-R is "etched" or "stained" with data, which induces much less scattering. Does this mean, then, that laser scattering induces bit errors? RH's reasoning, to me, would suggest no, since "bit-errors are virtually non-existent" and "bitstreams read from different media... can sound different from one another, but not because of data errors." In that case, there has to be some other explanation.

From what I understand, the two things that affect sound quality in front of the DAC are bit errors and jitter. In that case, CD-R discs must induce far less jitter than Red Book discs, especially if the difference in sound quality can be heard. If that is the case, then, the contention that CD-R's sound better is a bit odd because some CD players already have extremely low levels of jitter when playing back Red Book CD. Therefore the difference between a CD and its CD-R duplicate would essentially be inaudible.

Post new comment

This is a hidden form field please leave blank.
This is a hidden form field please leave blank.
This is a hidden form field please leave blank.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Each email address will be obfuscated in a human readable fashion or (if JavaScript is enabled) replaced with a spamproof clickable link.

More information about formatting options

You are seeing this because you do not have javascript enabled. Please enter the words "not spam" to continue sumbiting the form.