Well, I'll Be Damned: YG Acoustics Does a 180!

Posted by: Jonathan Valin at 4:04 pm, January 11th, 2010


 
See anything different about this year's YG Acoustics exhibit room? Yes, it's the same farchachdat gigantic echo chamber in the Sands Expo that YG played in in 2009, and, yes, those are the same $107k YG Anat Reference II Pros--this year driven (impressively well) by Krell electronics and my favorite digital, dCS. But...look at the walls.
 
Yup, according to none other than YG's Yoav  Geva, YG took my advice to heart when, after last year's fiasco, I asked Yoav if he had a death wish to show his statement products in such a horrendous room at such ear-splitting levels. Though I can scarcely believe that I was the only listener who complained about last year's acoustics, this time around Geva actually put room treatment on those thirty-foot-high walls  and--even more shocking--turned the volume down to less than Apollo 17-launch levels, and I gotta admit that the net effect of these changes was...astonishing. 
 
This is absolutely the first (and this far, only) time I have heard YG's statement speakers shown in YG's own room sound undeniably excellent. As with most of the other displays at CES, the Anat's overall balance was a bit on the dark side (i.e., weighted toward the lower mids and bass). Nonetheless, a touch of dark and rich and luscious is infinitely preferably to the plethora of thin, aggressive, and shriekingly bright I've heard at previous YG demos. This year, timbres were beautiful, and definition, dynamics, and sheer presence downright impressive, with wonderful control, detail, and extension in the bass (and everywhere else, actually). The Anats reproduced Marc Cohn's "Ghost Train"--a cut I'm very familiar with--with superior resolution of individual lines. And to be honest, this wasn't even the best YG  exhibit at CES. 
 
That honor would belong to Ted Denney of Synergistics Research, who was showing the smaller versions of the Anats--the Anat Reference II Studio (seen above in black immediately to the left of the taller silver Anat Reference II Pros)--in a much smaller and somewhat more gemutlich room with his own remarkable new gold/silver/platinum Galileo cable/interconnect system, and Acoustic ART room treatments. Though I'm not entirely sure that Ted's system wasn't a bit overdamped, I am sure that the sound was ravishing and as finely detailed as anything I heard at this year's show. I was particularly impressed by the way the system reproduced Cut 7 of The International--a vertitable torture test of multiple tones and textures and X-tra-large- and small-scale dynamics, Ted's various tweaks and the Anats themselves brought out tiny little details of attack, timbre, and decay that simply weren't as fully audible on most (not all) other systems. It also did a better-than-acceptable job of my Captain Luke cut, "Rainy Night In Hell."
 
While I wouldn't say that either Anat system was "absolute sound" realistic (and, of course, how could one say that about the synthesized soundtrack of The International), they were as good as hi-fi gets--the kind of sound that I think is tailor-made for those listeners I call the "as you like it" types, who want music to sound beautiful and thrilling, first and foremost. They are also quite the ticket for listeners in the "mastertape" camp, who want to hear every detail of music, mastering, and engineering reproduced with utter clarity. 
 
The YG Acoustics Anat may not be "The Best Loudspeaker On Earth. Period." (The phrase itself is silly, IMO.) But, this year, in two different rooms, the Anat was unquestionably "The Most Improved Loudspeaker On Earth. Period."

Comments

peterayer -- Tue, 01/12/2010 - 17:34

JV, Did you have a chance to hear the new YG $18K speaker? I assume it's that small one in the photo. I'd be very curious to know how it compares to the Magico V2. Thanks for the reporting.

Jonathan Valin -- Tue, 01/12/2010 - 17:39

No, I didn't hear the Kipod, which I liked a year ago at RMAF. You should read Robert's review of the Kipod in TAS.

peterayer -- Tue, 01/12/2010 - 18:41

Jonathan,
I'm talking about the new $18K speaker which launched at CES and must be a response to the Magico V2. I don't know what it's called. I did read Robert's Kipod review and was pleased to read something that was not an outright rave, but rather quite balanced. I'm looking for that great sub $20K speaker and am quite intrigued by the comparisons (or not) on these forums between YG and Magico.

Jonathan Valin -- Tue, 01/12/2010 - 23:40

Oh, I'm sorry. You're referring to the Carmel. I did not hear it, so cannot comment, but AlanTaffel should be reporting on it in TAS.

AlainB (not verified) -- Wed, 01/13/2010 - 13:03

The Carmel were horrendous. Both in sound and look.
Never heard the V2, but I can't imagine they will as bad.
For less money then the Carmel, try the small Focal.

Swen Mussanson (not verified) -- Thu, 01/14/2010 - 12:39

I have to agree with Mr. Valin. I was pleasantly surprised by the YG.

I must admit, though, that I *am* a YG fan (despite the commercials..), and I think you can't say the Carmel are horrendous. They sounded very, very well, and are going to be a worthy competitor IMO. As for the looks - Well, that's arguable :)

Ricardo Messeri (not verified) -- Fri, 01/15/2010 - 22:14

I am not impressed with the YG either. He has been showing the same stuff year after year. If you like the Aluminum look, the Piega or ELAC are better looking, much better sounding and less expensive. No wonder you do not see any YGs in Europe.

yoavgeva -- Wed, 02/17/2010 - 10:51

Dear Mr. Messeri,

While I have absolutely no problem with your opinion of our speakers, and you are definitely entitled to any opinion, I would kindly like to point out a factual error in your post, for fear that it might mislead some readers otherwise:

In fact, YG Acoustics has a substantial presence in Europe with an extensive distribution network throughout the continent. I do not know your location, and therefore do not know if we have a dealer in your precise vicinity. However, for your reference, below is a list of European countries in which we have a highly active dealer network, in no particular order:
Germany, Croatia, France, Belgium, Portugal, Russia, Serbia, Slovenia, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, U.K., Ireland.

It should also be noted that our company will be exhibiting this year again at the High End show in Munich, and I would like to take this opportunity to extend an invitation to visit us there, to you and to all forum readers.

Best regards,
Yoav Geva
President
YG Acoustics LLC

P.S. I listed U.K. and Ireland which, while not exactly continentally European, are viewed as such by some. Please excuse the geographical inaccuracy.

Dr. A. Tigrel (not verified) -- Tue, 02/02/2010 - 17:40

I fully agree with Jonathan Valin. In fact I will go a bit further and say that Anat Reference II Studio speakers are absolutely superb. It took me almost two years to decide to replace my Nova Utopia Be speakers with the Anats. Having had the Anats in my lounge for over a week now I think they are one of the best speakers I've heard in my audiophile life of almost 40 years. Their transparency and sounstaging are transcendant. 3D layering of instruments is never short of astounding. Resolution of low level detail is absolutely phenomenal.
I am using the Anats with Krell's EVO 1 and EVO 2 amplifiers. The front end includes Accuphase 800&801 units. Power cabling is Shunyata Research Anaconda and Nordost Valhalla. Speaker cabling and interconnects are Nordost Valhalla and Transparent Audio Reference. In brief, if you drive the Anats with comparably high quality gesr the results could be overwhelming.