JV’s 2009 “Extra” Golden Ear Awards

Posted by: Jonathan Valin at 3:03 pm, February 21st, 2009

This year we limited ourselves to two Golden Ear awards apiece. I’m not going to tell you which two products I picked—for that you’ll have to wait for Issue 193 of TAS—but I am going to pay a little attention here to those products that were in the running but didn’t make the final cut. In the past, when we weren’t restricted to just two top picks, all of these would’ve been awarded Golden Ears by me.

 
First, the Symposium Acoustics Isis equipment stand, Rollerblock Series II, and Ultra equipment platform. There are a lot of stands, cones, and platforms out there, folks, but these are the ones I would buy with my own money. Symposium’s Peter Bizlewicz has two patents on the Isis equipment stand, which uses his Rollerblock technology (an ingenious tungsten-carbide ball-bearing-based isolation system), his constrained-layer-damped Svelte Shelves, his Lightning Rod struts (made of solid aircraft-grade aluminum), and several other damping techniques. Like Peter’s constrained-layer Ultra platforms and his Rollerblocks, the isolation that the Isis provides for gear that is markedly affected by vibration, such as turntables and tonearms, is clearly audible. When I compared the Isis topped with an Ultra to an ultra-high-mass stand using the same turntable, the difference in the audibility of heavy footfalls on loose floorboards was astonishing. I could literally jump up and down beside the ’table mounted on the Isis/Ultra without disturbing the tonearm. http://www.symposiumusa.com/products.shtml
 
Second, the Air Tight PC-1 Supreme phono cartridge. Along with the DaVinci “Grandezza Reference” and the Clearaudio Goldfinger v2, this is the highest-fidelity moving-coil cartridge I’ve heard—a huge improvement over the original PC-1, which wasn’t chopped liver. The Supreme is much more finely detailed, much more extended in the bass, much richer in tone color, and overall much more dynamic than the original. Though not quite as neutral and transparent to sources as the DaVinci Grandezza or as wide open and dynamic as the Goldfinger, the Supreme is denser in timbre and more gemütlich than either. http://www.axissaudio.com/allComp.htm
 
Third, Tara Labs Omega Gold speaker cables and Zero Gold interconnects. You may recall that I rave-reviewed the Tara Labs’ Omega speaker cable and Zero several years ago, declaring them to be the best I’d heard. Well, the best got better. The Omega Gold, in particular, astonished me. I didn’t think that the original Omega—so detailed, so dynamic, so sensational in the bass octaves—could be enhanced this significantly, but, folks, this is an order of magnitude improvement. Part of the credit, it appears, must go to the way the Omega Gold is terminated—or should I say, not terminated. Unlike the original Omega, there are no spades or bananas or provision for the attachment of same with the Gold, which only has tinned “tags” of bare wire at either end. Apparently no solder joints are superior to even the best solder joints, because the difference here in resolution, transparency, neutrality, and sheer naturalness is marked. If there is better wire to be had, I haven’t heard it yet. http://www.taralabs.com/products.asp
 
Fourth, Feickert Adjust+. For those of you heavily into vinyl, the Feickert Adjust+ is a must-own. Using this software/hardware kit with your PC permits you to set sometimes tough-to-get-just-right things like azimuth or turntable speed with a precision that is standard-setting. Adjust+ also lets you literally measure the level and phase of crosstalk (to optimize channel separation), wow and flutter, cartridge/tonearm resonance, even THD. A snap to install and use, Adjust+ is a supremely intelligent solution to a whole bunch of analog problems. http://www.feickert.com/

Comments

kodg -- Tue, 02/24/2009 - 07:57

 
 
Dear Johnathan aim in cleveland, & would like a pro to come out & balance my sound system.  any recommendations?
 
thanks,
kodg
 
kodg [at] verizon [dot] net

Jonathan Valin -- Wed, 02/25/2009 - 23:48

 Kodg,
 
If there is an audio society in the Cleveland area, you might want to talk to one of its members.
 
Jon

James B -- Thu, 02/26/2009 - 19:05

I am happy to see the Isis Rack finally get credit it deserves!  (I bought a 5-shelf rack with turntable top, with my own money, then reconfigured with 2 more shelves into 2 racks, one with 3-shelves and the other with 4 shelves.)  Now that the "jump-in-front-of-turntable-on-wood-floor" test has been legitimized, I'll admit to trying it and getting the same result -- but never when anyone was around to see!   Besides “macro” isolation, though, the whole sonic presentation in my system has opened up significantly, with more layering, clarity, cleaner bass, all even moreso with Rollerblocks in strategic locations -- often imitated, never equaled.  For me they made the greatest difference under the linestage but that is probably system dependent.  
The turntable top is essentially an oversized top shelf.  Adding to the rack's isolation effects, I use Rollerblock Jrs. with “spacers” under the plinth of my TNT turntable, such that the plinth is slightly elevated and Jrs support its full weight -- the VPI suspension is totally out of play -– and what a nice sonic improvement!    
 

James B.

John Thayer (not verified) -- Thu, 02/26/2009 - 19:32

Hi Jon
Nice to see your 2009 "Extra" Golden Ear award for the Symposium Isis stand and isolation devices.  I have used the Symposium Isis rack, Rollerblock Jr's, at Ultra platforms for several years.  I think the build quality, aesthetics and  innovative isolation principles all combine to make a statement product.  I haven't seen or heard anything I like better.  The performance of my Basis 2500 turntable on an Ultra with the Isis rack is world class.  The BAT SE gear is also very happy "floating" on tungston balls!
Those Symposium Panorama speakers aren't bad either are they?  WOW!!

Bill Leebens (not verified) -- Fri, 02/27/2009 - 16:44

Hi Jon-- kodg, contact Don Better at Don Better Audio in Cleveland. He's a pro musician, music teacher, record producer--and, oh, sells audio gear. He's your guy. Cheers, Bill

Taj Madiwale (not verified) -- Fri, 03/06/2009 - 08:25

Hi Jonathan,
I've been a fan for years and respect your opinions.  I am in the market for a new CD player and I love my Audio Research Ref 3 preamp and I know you have given great reviews to the Ref CD 7 player and was wondering if you are going to audition the new Ref CD 8 player and do a comparison.  My alternative pick is the Esoteric X03-SE CD/SACD player.   What is your take on it?  Also, I have taken your advice about the Shunyata dark field elevators.  They really do work.  I also want to try the Shakti halographs but was wondering if it would be problematic for my setup since I have Magnepan 20.1s that have rear firing.  Will the halographs mess this up if placed behind them?  Should I position them in some other configuration?  What are your recommendations?
Thanks,
Taj

All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1999 - 2011 NextScreen. All Rights Reserved.
Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.