Inside the YG Acoustics Factory

Posted by: Robert Harley at 10:10 am, February 21st, 2009

Inside the YG Acoustics Factory
Robert Harley
 
YG Acoustics is a relatively young company (founded in 2002) that has made quite a splash in the upper-end of the loudspeaker market. The firm has attracted some fervent proponents along with controversy surrounding its key marketing slogan: “The Best Loudspeaker on Earth. Period.” This statement, along with the products’ pricing and unusual build, tends to polarize audiophiles, exemplified by the thread on our forum “Are YG Acoustics Hype or the Real Deal?” http://www.avguide.com/forums/are-yg-speakers-hype-or-the-real-deal
            To cut through the noise, I visited YG Acoustics’ factory in Arvada, Colorado (a Denver suburb). I learned that Yoav Geva, YG Acoustics’ founder, based the loudspeakers’ design on an analog application of a digital-signal processing algorithm he developed that allowed simultaneous optimization of signals in the amplitude and time domains. When used in loudspeakers, this technique reportedly results in flat frequency response and nearly perfect phase response. The “Best Loudspeaker on Earth” claim stems from what YG claims is the flattest frequency response and best phase response of any loudspeaker.
 
 

Yoav Geva with the Anat Reference II Professional
 
            YG builds the loudspeakers from scratch inside its 6000-square-foot, seven-employee factory. The enclosures are all made from solid blocks of aircraft-grade aluminum. (The baffles of the Anat Main Module are ballistic-grade aluminum, which has some titanium in it.) Aluminum is an ideal material for speaker enclosures because of its stiffness. The company owns the very expensive (and reportedly top-of-the-line) milling and grinding machines for working the metal. Raw aluminum sheets, some of them weighing three-quarters of a ton, are moved via an overhead crane system. The panels that make up the enclosure are cut and drilled, and then ground to create the finish you see on the final product. The panels are then anodized by an outside facility.
 

An overhead crane picks up sheets of raw aluminum
 

Baffles ready for anodizing
 

Panel grinding
 
            One model loudspeaker is built at a time with drivers that have been individually tested and measured. The data on each driver are archived so that if a customer needs a replacement driver, one of nearly identical characteristics can be substituted. Each speaker’s crossover is tuned to match the set of drivers going into the enclosure. The crossovers use the huge (and extraordinarily expensive) Mundorf capacitors. All the drivers are sourced from ScanSpeak and are either custom-made for YG or re-built by YG to its specifications. The tweeter in the Anat, for example, uses a diaphragm from Germany and ScanSpeak’s motor structure, with final assembly performed in YG’s factory.  
ere            
A Mundorf capacitor
 
The facility felt more like a craft shop than an industrial factory. There was a perfectionist attitude toward every aspect of production, and the pace was slow and deliberate. The metalwork was exquisite.
 
The YG line starts with the $17k Kipod, a small two-way that can be stand mounted or turned into a full-range floorstanding speaker with the addition of a woofer base. The full-range system is called the Kipod Studio, and sells for $38k. The woofer enclosure can be ordered as a passive system, or an active woofer driven by an integral power amplifier.
 

Kipod Studio
 
            The Anat Reference II line begins with the $33k Anat Main Module. As with the Kipod, the Anat Main Module can be used on its own or mounted on a woofer. This configuration is the $70k Anat Reference II Studio, and can be ordered with a passive or actively powered woofer (the price is the same). The top-of-the-line is the Anat Reference II Professional, which adds a second woofer enclosure. The price is $107k. A customer can add woofer modules at any time.
 
 

YG's top-of-the-line, $107k Anat Reference II Professional
 
            I heard the Anat Reference II in the company’s factory showroom. The playback system included a Krell Evolution 202 preamp, Krell FBB 400CX power amplifiers, and a dCS Scarlatti stack as the digital front-end, all connected with Kimber interconnects and speaker cable. A pair of Wilson X-2s (Series 1) was on hand for comparison, although I don’t know how well they were set-up and optimized (the X-2 Series 2 in my listening room sound vastly better.) I’d heard YG speakers before at shows, with mixed results. The ballrooms at the Venetian are not kind to any loudspeaker, and the Anat’s best qualities tended to be obscured by the room. On the other hand, the Kipod Studio sounded fabulous at the most recent Rocky Mountain Audio Fest. This small speaker had tremendous clarity, dynamics, resolution, and a sense of life and presence that brought the music out of the speakers and into the room.
 

YG's listening room
 
            The Anat Reference II Professional in YG’s showroom sounded very much like what I heard from the Kipod Studio at the Rocky Mountain show, but taken to another level. The Anat’s best quality was a clarity in the midrange and treble that was the antithesis of thick, smeared, or confused. Instruments hung in transparent space, completely detached from the loudspeakers. Dynamics were also this speaker’s strong suit; it started and stopped on a dime in the midband, infusing instruments with visceral palpability. The two acoustic guitars on the wonderful self-titled disc Rodrigo y Gabriela were lightning quick, but without a trace of etch or hardness. Similarly, the Anat has, in spades, what Jonathan Valin aptly calls “action”—the sense of bloom expanding around an instrument’s dynamic envelope. The most vivid example of “action” that I know of is the trombone solo on the track “Soft Winds” from the Dick Hyman From the Age of Swing on Reference Recordings. With the right loudspeaker, the trombone fairly jumps out of the soundstage right into your face, much the way the instrument does in life. It had a tremendous “blat” without the glare that can make the sound painful when played at a lifelike level. These qualities added up to a presentation that was extremely lively, detailed, and viscerally engaging. It is impossible to evaluate a loudspeaker—especially one of this ambition—in a couple of hours of listening, and in a less-than-optimum room (the room had a drop ceiling, for example). Nonetheless, I concluded that the Anat is a serious product from a serious company.
            Watch for a full review of the Kipod Studio in an upcoming issue.
 

Comments

HERKIE THE CAT (not verified) -- Mon, 02/23/2009 - 03:57

***comment-- this is a series speaker i want to hear is there a dealer in the phyladelphia pa area?***
ALSO, IS THE RECORDING  OF DICK HYMAN FROM THE AGE OF SWING LP OR CD---PLEASE

Robert Harley -- Mon, 02/23/2009 - 14:54

You should contact YG to see if they have a dealer in your area. From the Age of Swing was on HDCD-encoded CD.

blackfly -- Wed, 02/25/2009 - 14:31

You point out the comparison is between X-2 series 1 and series 2 and state the series 2 are vastly better.  So how is this supposed to make owners of the series 1 feel.  At the price I expect perfection first time, no excuses.  Personally I like the YG and can appreciate the CNC machined cabinet and the obvious benefits it offers.  It would be on a short list if I could only afford it.

John Thayer (not verified) -- Wed, 02/25/2009 - 20:44

Excellent overview of the YG..  I heard the RMAF 08 demo.  Very interesting to see all the work that goes into the product.  I think that Magico, MBL, Symposium, and Focal might have some thoughts about the YG claim of "Best Loudspeaker on Earth.  Period"  Based on my experience the Wilson X2 Series 2 is the standard by which all others are measured. 
It is surprising that the YG listening room and the Wilson X1's were not optomized. 
Great photos.

Phil Schneider (not verified) -- Fri, 02/27/2009 - 10:35

It has to be part of marketing a $107K audio product that it's listening room should also be "The best listening room on earth".
 To bring an audio product reviewer into a less than "special" listening room has to be a error in judgement especially when the product built is to be compared to the Wison, one of the world's acknowledged best.
 

Charlie TW (not verified) -- Sat, 02/28/2009 - 14:38


Dear Phil:
To refer to the "special listening room treatment", this is an addendum photo that was just taken at my showroom in Taipei,Taiwan
This is a dedicated listening room that are adopted with ESR Acoustics from Greece. 
They work harmonically well and blending the sound from top to the bottom.
No matter how huge the speaker it is,they just disappear ......  
Cheers 
 
Charlie Hus
Sound Roof Audio,Taipei,Taiwan

Jim Hannon -- Sat, 02/28/2009 - 10:06

Thanks, Robert, for such an informative post. It's great to get a "behind the scenes" glimpse and as John said, "Great photos."

Anonymous (not verified) -- Mon, 03/02/2009 - 01:34

 hello Yg
 
              sir do u have any dealer in india .kindly update us in this reg.
                                                                                                                 sk
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Anonymous (not verified) -- Wed, 03/04/2009 - 04:08

Hi,
Friend from India, why not you put up wanted on http://cgi.audiogon.com/cgi-bin/srch_fs.pl

Anonymous (not verified) -- Wed, 03/04/2009 - 21:50

It always concerns me to hear of a company making such silly claims as "the best".  This company even reports having "the top of the line" milling and grinding equipment.  As an owner of a CNC machine shop utilizing 7 different machine tool brands and over 20 machine tools I can tell you that none of them are "the best"...rather they are all unique for a unique purpose.  I make no Hi-Fi or Lo-Fi products...I am merely enjoying a hobby and am tired of reading rediculous claims of "the best" this or that in our subjective hobby.  With that said I have not heard this company's product and I wish them all the best...including a chance to prove me wrong.  Who knows, maybe they will be my music nirvana!  (Just leave the hype to the sports talk shows)

Yoav Geva (not verified) -- Wed, 03/11/2009 - 17:43

Dear Anonymous (there are several messages by Anonymous, so I am referring this time to the CNC machine shop owner),
Please allow me to respond to your interesting and highly relevant message:
You are, of course, correct that CNC machines are application-specific, and therefore when we say "top of the line", we simply mean 2 things:
1. That they are the top-of-the-line models of their respective manufacturers for our application.
2. That they are the best-suited machines for our applications, that we could find from any manufacturer.
You may notice that we have never made claims to own the "best CNC machines", so please take that into account.
As for claiming that our speakers are "the best", here I stand by the bold claim, although I (of course) don't expect you to take my word for it. Rather, I hope that you take the time to audition my products, and decide for yourself whether you agree. May I cordially invite you to audition our products?
May I take this opportunity to invite you to also tour the factory, just as Robert Harley has done, since you are obviously intimately familiar with machining and production processes, and your opinion would be highly valued?
Best regards,
Yoav Geva
YG Acoustics

Anonymous (not verified) -- Sat, 03/07/2009 - 03:34

So the makers of the best speaker in the world cannot afford or find the resources to build a decent listening showroom?
And hasn't anyone heard of single speaker demonstrations? Placing 2 pairs of huge speakers so close together, even just in the same room, will have a huge impact on the sound.
I simply cannot take this effort too seriously. Smacks of...let's make em real big and expensive call em the best and see what happens. Seen the Emperor's clothes anyone?

Yoav Geva (not verified) -- Wed, 03/11/2009 - 18:03

Dear Anonymous (there are several messages by Anonymous, so I am referring this time to the complaint about our showroom setup),
First of all, you are correct that our listening room is far from being the "Taj Mahal" of audio. It is a showroom inside a factory, and while I do not consider it to be bad in any way, it is far from perfect.
Please understand that when we allocate resources to various projects in our company, the top priority always goes to things that allow our product to be of the finest quality (such as R&D, manufacturing equipment, and hiring highly-qualified engineers and master-craftsmen). Things such as decorating the factory-showroom are inevitably pushed to a lower priority, especially since many customers can experience our products through in-home auditions conducted by the local dealer.
Last but not least, you are right that removing one speaker from the showroom when playing the other is beneficial, and we indeed do so when conductin our own "internal" critical listening. However, with the speakers mentioned weighing 440 lbs and 800 lbs respectively, it is an operation that cannot be performed during a regular visit. In order to partially mitigate the effect of the additional speaker in the room, we do short-out its inputs.
Let me also state, for the record, that our setup of the Wilsons was done extremely meticulously, following their instruction manual and using their recommended methods to a tee. We have also verified, using measurements, that the setup position is optimal. The difference that Robert Harley has heard is probably due to the fact that we have an X2 series 1 on display, whereas he has the series 2. There are 4 years separating the two versions, so I trust that there would be sonic differences.
Of course, when a dealer trades-in a pair of X2 series 2, we would be happy to offer a comparative audition with that speaker as well :-)
Best,
Yoav Geva
YG Acoustics

Anonymous - Series 2 (not verified) -- Fri, 04/24/2009 - 14:25

Dear All and particularly Yoav Geva,
What makes you think Wilson X-2 (series 1 or 2) is the reference loudspeaker to compare to? I think you should compare "your best" with a "real best" loudspeaker from a manufacturer who conducts real R&D in appropriate facilites, (an unechoic chamber for example), and also manufactures its own "drivers" through its own technology with more than just "seven employee".
Sorry to remind you that high-end audio is in fact a serious industry.

wd3 -- Fri, 05/22/2009 - 15:27

I always see the speakers in silver polish,are they availible in other colors?
 
 

Abdullah Al Futtaim (not verified) -- Sat, 02/20/2010 - 02:21

While the Anat Reference II Professional may or may not be the "best speaker in the world", it is heads and shoulders above the Magico M5. I had the pleasure of listening to a shoot-out conducted by my local club in one of our members' homes. I was stunned at how good the YG was, or perhaps, more shocked at how disappointing the M5 was. It sounded lifeless and harsh compared to the Anat, which to be fair, costs a tiny bit more than the Magico. It should really cost 10 times more because that's how much better it is than the M5. I've heard the Alexandria X-2 S2s and I say the Wilsons are close to the Anats, but the Magicos shouldn't even be in this conversation. Maybe they would do well compared to Paradigm and KEF, but no way are they in this league. Everything was being run through Soulution 700 amps so maybe that had something to do with it. Maybe it's not a good match with the Magico but they made the Anats sing! I have no idea how the M5 come to its reputation with the muddy bass, messy imaging, unbalanced soundstage. It's like every testimonial I've read online is just rubbish made up by some marketing firm. The M5s we heard that night was provided by the dealer hoping he would sell a pair or two to us, but it was pretty unanimous amongst our group that the M5 was not a top performer that we expected. While the Anats are expensive, the shoot-out convinced another of our group to order his own pair. Just fantastic!

yoavgeva -- Sat, 02/20/2010 - 23:34

Dear Mr. Al-Futtaim,
While I definitely appreciate your enthusiasm with YG Acoustics speakers, I have not heard of the shootout that you are referring to. This is a bit unusual, since typically I keep pretty good track of events worldwide, especially of this scale.
Could you please elaborate a bit on where this event was held?
Best,
Yoav Geva, YG Acoustics

yoavgeva -- Sat, 02/20/2010 - 23:20

While I appreciate your enthusiasm, I have never heard of the demo that you are referring to. This is a bit unusual, since typically I keep pretty good tabs on demos, especially of this scale.
Could you please elaborate a bit on where this demo was held?
Sincerely,
Yoav Geva
YG Acoustics LLC